# [How to negotiate realtor fees as a seller or buyer](https://www.trymumm.com/guides/how-to-negotiate-realtor-fees)

> Realtor fees are negotiable on both sides of a home sale and are not set by law. Sellers negotiate the listing commission, and whether to pay anything toward a buyer’s agent, in the listing agreement. Buyers negotiate their own agent’s pay in the written agreement they now sign before touring, and can ask the seller to cover some or all of it in the offer.

- **Updated:** 2026-11-15
- **Category:** Homes
- **Read time:** 12 min

## Can you negotiate realtor commission?

Yes. No law sets a commission rate, and since August 17, 2024 the paperwork says so. Under the practice changes that followed the National Association of Realtors settlement, Realtors and MLS participants must state in conspicuous language that broker fees are fully negotiable and not set by law. That statement appears in listing agreements, written buyer agreements and agency disclosure forms.

What you negotiate depends on which side of the sale you are on. A seller hires a listing agent and agrees on that agent’s pay. A buyer hires a buyer’s agent and agrees on that agent’s pay. The seller may also choose to cover part of the buyer’s costs, which links the two conversations.

**Who negotiates which realtor fee, and where it is written down**

| Fee | Negotiated between | Where the terms live | What you can change |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Listing commission | Seller and listing agent | Listing agreement | Rate or flat amount, tiers, listing length, cancellation terms, what marketing is included |
| Buyer’s agent pay | Buyer and buyer’s agent | Written buyer agreement, signed before the first tour | Amount, how it is calculated, length of the agreement, which homes or areas it covers, services included |
| Seller payment toward the buyer’s agent | Buyer and seller, through the offer | Purchase contract or a separate written agreement | Whether the seller pays, how much, and how it trades against price |
| Seller concessions | Buyer and seller | Purchase contract | A credit toward the buyer’s closing costs, subject to the loan type’s limits |
| Broker administrative or transaction fees | Each client and their brokerage | Listing or buyer agreement | Whether the fee applies at all, and its amount |

## What changed with the NAR settlement in 2024

Before August 2024, a listing agent usually advertised on the MLS what share of the commission a buyer’s agent would get. Buyers rarely negotiated their agent’s pay because the seller’s side had already set it. The new rules separate the two fees and put each one in front of the client who agrees to it.

- Offers of compensation to buyer’s agents can no longer appear on an MLS. Sellers can still make them through other channels, such as the listing brokerage’s own website, flyers or direct conversation.
- A listing agent must disclose in writing, and get the seller’s approval for, any payment or offer of payment to an agent working for buyers, with the amount or rate, before it is made.
- An agent working with a buyer must have a signed written agreement before the buyer tours a home, in person or by live video, unless state law requires one even earlier.
- That agreement must state the agent’s pay in objective terms and say that fees are fully negotiable and not set by law.
- The buyer’s agent cannot receive more from any source than the agreement allows.
- Sellers can still advertise concessions on an MLS, such as help with closing costs, as long as the concession does not depend on the buyer using or paying an agent.

These are NAR and MLS rules, not federal law. The U.S. Department of Justice told the court in November 2024 that the settlement did not limit its own antitrust enforcement, and it raised concerns about the pre-tour agreement requirement. Your state’s real estate laws still govern agency relationships and disclosures, so the exact forms you sign vary by state.

## How to negotiate realtor fees as a seller

The listing commission comes out of your sale proceeds at closing, so whatever you negotiate off it stays with you. NAR’s own guidance is that listing agreements can be structured however the seller and listing broker agree, as long as the agreement complies with the law and states the amount or rate. That flexibility is your leverage.

- Interview at least three listing agents. Ask each for a written proposal that covers the fee, the marketing plan, the pricing strategy and who handles showings and negotiation.
- Ask each agent to show recent sales of homes like yours that they listed, with the list price, sale price and days on market.
- Name the structure you want rather than asking for a discount in general. A flat fee, a lower percentage or a tiered rate are all easier to say yes to than a vague request.
- Negotiate the listing length and the cancellation clause. A shorter term, or the right to cancel if the agent does not deliver the agreed marketing, keeps the agent working for the fee.
- Ask which costs the commission covers. Professional photos, staging, video tours and paid advertising are sometimes included and sometimes billed separately.
- Decide in advance how you will handle requests to pay toward a buyer’s agent, so it does not get settled by default.

### Commission structures to put on the table

**Listing commission structures a seller can propose**

| Structure | How it works | When it fits |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Lower flat percentage | A single rate applied to the sale price | A home that will sell quickly in an active market |
| Flat fee | A fixed dollar amount, whatever the sale price | A higher-priced home where a percentage would far exceed the work involved |
| Tiered or incentive rate | A lower rate up to a target price and a higher rate on the amount above it | Rewarding the agent for a stronger sale price rather than a fast one |
| Reduced rate if the agent finds the buyer | A lower total when the listing brokerage also represents the buyer | States that allow dual or designated agency, with your written consent |
| Limited service | A lower fee for an MLS listing and paperwork, with you handling showings or negotiation | Sellers with time, local knowledge and comfort negotiating directly |

## Should the seller pay the buyer’s agent?

Sellers are no longer expected to set a buyer-agent payment before listing, but buyers can still ask for one in their offers. Some buyers cannot pay their agent in cash on top of a down payment and closing costs, and NAR notes that a commission cannot be added to the mortgage balance. Offering to help can widen your pool of buyers. Refusing can keep more of the proceeds. Neither choice is fixed until you sign something.

Treat a request to pay the buyer’s agent as part of the price. An offer at one price with a seller-paid agent fee nets you less than the same price without it. Compare offers by what you keep after every fee and credit, not by the headline number. You can also offer a general credit toward the buyer’s closing costs instead, which the buyer can use for their agent or other costs within their loan’s limits.

Your listing agent must present every offer. Under Realtor Standard of Practice 16-16, a buyer’s agent can make seller-paid compensation a term of the offer, but an agent cannot delay or withhold delivering the offer while negotiating their own compensation. If you agree to pay a buyer’s agent, your listing agent must get your written approval with the amount or rate before any payment is promised.

## How to negotiate a buyer’s agent fee before you tour

Buyers now negotiate their agent’s pay at the start of the relationship, before the first showing. The written buyer agreement must give the pay in objective terms, such as a flat fee, a percentage of the price or an hourly rate. It cannot be open-ended, such as whatever the seller decides to offer, and it cannot be a range. NAR’s guidance lists $0 as a valid amount, and it leaves the type of relationship, the length of the agreement and the services to the buyer and the brokerage.

That gives you more to negotiate than the fee itself:

- Length. NAR’s examples range from one day to one month. A short first agreement lets you try an agent before committing.
- Scope. An agreement can cover one house, one zip code or one type of property, so a tour of a single home does not tie you to that agent for your whole search.
- Exclusivity. A nonexclusive agreement lets you work with more than one brokerage. NAR describes buyers signing nonexclusive agreements with several brokerages, with disputes over pay decided by which agent actually brought about the sale.
- Services. List what the fee covers: showings, comparable-sales analysis, offer writing, negotiation, inspection follow-up and closing coordination. A smaller list can justify a smaller fee.
- Shortfall terms. Find the clause that says what happens if the seller pays less than the agreed fee. If it makes you responsible for the difference, work out the most you could owe before you sign.

Interview agents the way a seller would. Ask each for a sample agreement before you tour anything, compare the fee and the services side by side, and ask how they handle a home where the seller offers nothing toward their pay. You do not need an agreement to talk with an agent, to ask about their services or to walk through an open house.

## Ask the seller to cover your agent’s fee

Your agreement sets what your agent earns. Who pays it is a separate negotiation with the seller, and you can raise it in your offer. NAR confirms a buyer can ask the listing agent or the seller to pay their agent. The answer changes how much cash you need at closing.

- Decide before writing the offer whether to ask for full coverage, partial coverage or a general closing-cost credit.
- Weigh the request against price. A seller may accept a slightly higher price with the fee covered, or a lower price without it. Run both against your monthly payment and cash to close.
- Put any seller payment in the purchase contract or a separate signed agreement. A spoken promise from the listing agent does not bind the seller.
- If the seller offers more than your agreement allows, your agent cannot keep the excess. Ask for the difference as a lower price or a credit instead.
- Ask your lender how a seller-paid agent fee is treated for your loan. NAR says Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and FHA guidance does not count it against the seller-concession limits. VA buyers should confirm the current VA rules with their lender, because they have changed since 2024.

## Word-for-word scripts for the fee conversation

Specific requests get specific answers. Use these as written and fill in your own numbers.

### Seller, to a listing agent you are interviewing

> I am interviewing three agents to list my home and will decide by [date]. Please send a written proposal with your commission, what it includes and how long the listing would run. I am looking for [a flat fee of amount / a rate of X percent / a lower rate up to amount and a higher rate above it]. I also want to know how you would handle offers that ask me to pay the buyer’s agent, since I will decide that offer by offer.

### Buyer, to a buyer’s agent before the first tour

> Before we tour, I would like to agree on your fee in writing. I am proposing [flat amount or rate] for the services we discussed, under a [one-month / single-property] nonexclusive agreement to start. If a seller agrees to pay part of your fee, that amount reduces what I owe. Can you send me your agreement with those terms so I can review it today?

## Flat-fee, discount and limited-service brokerages

If a full-service agent will not move enough, other business models charge less by doing less or by working at volume. Ask any of them for a written list of what is included, because the savings come from somewhere.

- Flat-fee MLS listing. The broker puts your home on the MLS for a set fee and you handle showings, questions and negotiation. Your state may require brokers to provide certain minimum services, so ask what this broker must do for you.
- Discount full-service brokerage. A lower rate for a full listing, often with salaried agents or a team handling showings. Ask who will be at your showings and who will negotiate offers.
- Flat-fee or hourly buyer’s agent. You pay for the help you use, such as offer writing and negotiation, after finding homes yourself.
- Commission rebate. Some buyer’s agents credit part of their fee back to you at closing. State rules on rebates vary, and your lender must allow the credit. On the Closing Disclosure, a rebate appears as a credit naming the agent who gives it.
- No agent at all. A buyer or seller can work without an agent, often with a real estate attorney handling the contract and closing.

## Dual agency rules vary by state

In dual agency, one agent represents both the seller and the buyer. In designated agency, one brokerage represents both, with different agents assigned to each side. Some states prohibit dual agency, others allow it with written consent, and some use different relationships such as transaction brokers. The CFPB advises buyers to ask how an agent or brokerage would handle a home you like when it also represents the seller, and whether your conversations stay confidential.

If you agree to dual or designated agency, the fee is still negotiable. A buyer working with the listing agent still needs a written buyer agreement under the new rules, and the agency disclosure form must say that fees are negotiable. Sellers who expect this can write a lower total commission into the listing agreement for when the listing brokerage also brings the buyer.

## Check the agent fees on your Closing Disclosure

The Closing Disclosure is where the negotiated numbers become final. Under the CFPB’s Regulation Z commentary, the commission shown must be the total paid to any real estate brokerage. Other charges from a brokerage or agent, such as an administrative or transaction fee, are listed separately with a description and the name of the person receiving the payment.

Buyers get the Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing. Sellers get their own closing statement showing the commissions deducted from their proceeds. Compare each commission and broker fee line with your signed agreements and the purchase contract. A broker fee that was never in your agreement is worth questioning before you sign, not after.

## Take your terms to the seller

When you have picked a home and decided what you want, including whether the seller should cover your agent’s fee or give a closing-cost credit, Mumm can take that request to the seller or the listing agent and bring back their answer. Mumm is not a brokerage and does not replace your agent. If you want a fee proposal put to an agent you have chosen, Mumm can take that request to them too. You decide what to accept, and your maximum stays private.

## Questions people actually ask



## What is the typical realtor commission?

There is no standard rate. Commissions are set by agreement between each client and their agent, and since August 2024 the agreements must say they are fully negotiable and not set by law. Get written proposals from several agents in your area and compare what each fee includes.

## Do sellers still pay the buyer’s agent commission?

Only if they agree to. Sellers can no longer advertise buyer-agent compensation on the MLS, but they can still offer it through other channels or agree to it in a purchase contract. Many buyers ask for it in their offer, and the seller weighs it as part of the price.

## Do I have to sign a buyer agreement to see a house?

If an MLS participant is working with you, yes, before you tour a home in person or by live video. You do not need one to visit an open house, to talk with an agent about their services, or when the listing agent shows you the home while representing only the seller.

*Truncated to fit size budget; remaining content omitted.*